Is Sydney Sweeney’s Anyone But You the grand return of the mediocre rom-com?

It has been launched on streaming platforms and solely has a 54% on Rotten Tomatoes – but movie-goers are nonetheless leaving residence to see the mid-budget flick. Why?

Anybody However You, the brand new movie starring Sydney Sweeney and Glen Powell, is getting followers to the theatre. The movie, a modernised tackle Shakespeare’s A lot Ado About Nothing from director Will Gluck, was launched on 26 December 2023, and has been a slow-yet regular burn on the field workplace. After this previous weekend, the little romantic comedy that might has earned £163m ($207m) globally, surging previous The Marvels.

The film follows Bea (Sweeney) and Ben (Powell), who discover themselves pressured collectively throughout a marriage after their extraordinary first date goes dangerous. Plot-wise, it is nothing groundbreaking. But it has grabbed the eye of movie-goers – together with Risa Bramon Garcia, a producer and casting director who labored on movies similar to True Romance, 200 Cigarettes, and exhibits like The Affair and Gilmore Ladies: A 12 months In The Life. She tells BBC Tradition that she intends to see the movie largely due to its recognition within the zeitgeist proper now. Whereas loads of folks love “a good rom com”, she says, “this one in particular has taken hold” of movie-goer curiosity. 

Certainly, Anybody However You’s field workplace success is intriguing, particularly as a result of romantic comedies have not gotten folks off the sofa the best way they as soon as did in additional than a decade. Based on a 2023 Reuters report, the Nineteen Nineties by way of 2000s was the “golden age” for romantic comedies – kicked off little doubt by 1989’s When Harry Met Sally. Movies similar to Sleepless in Seattle, My Finest Good friend’s Wedding ceremony and Notting Hill, to call just a few, had movie-goers lined up on the field workplace window – with the 2002 flick My Massive Fats Greek Wedding ceremony maybe studying from its decade of profitable 90s predecessors to develop into the best grossing rom-com of all time at £290m ($368.7m).

Whereas followers may keep in mind the titles (and the funniest or most heartfelt strains) of the 90s and early-noughties golden age fondly, some feminine stars who have been identified for his or her rom-com performances, felt betrayed by the best way their movies have been finally considered. In a 2022 interview with the New York Instances, Sandra Bullock, who starred in movies similar to Miss Congeniality and Whereas You Have been Sleeping, revealed that she stopped making rom-coms on goal as a result of she felt they have been “undervalued”. She was being type-cast into the roles, she mentioned, whereas males who made rom coms weren’t subjected to the identical destiny. 

Extra like this:

“Anytime someone said ‘chick flick’ or ‘rom-com’, it was just disparaging,” Bullock informed the Instances. “I believe when all the things swung towards the very masculine action-adventure, girls bought relegated to the arm piece, or the damsel in misery. Then, when rom-coms got here again in it was all the time like, ‘Oh, we’ll let the ladies come again in, but it surely’s going to be this method that we like, and it could actually’t be too edgy.” 

While some erstwhile romantic comedy stars began choosing different roles, by 2010, another sea change was evident: movie-goers weren’t shelling out for tickets to rom coms. Interest had fallen, and Hollywood producers started to bet, instead, on superhero action films. 

Scott Meslow, film critic and author of From Hollywood with Love: The Rise and Fall (and Rise Again) of the Romantic Comedy tells BBC Culture that while there has “all the time been an viewers for rom coms”, mid-budget films faded out. “At a time when Hollywood was more and more betting on $200-plus million blockbusters with hopes of a billion-dollar gross (and a cinematic universe) – or, on the opposite finish, a smaller-scale ‘status’ film that may win a Finest Image Oscar – rom-coms have been uniquely devalued within the market.” 

Now, Anyone But You’s box office success has critics wondering if rom coms are coming back in full force. After all, the film didn’t have a big budget – £19.7m ($25m) as opposed to the Marvels £190m ($240m). It didn’t have special effects, superheroes or even the draw of tropical scenery. Plus, it’s already been released to stream on AppleTV and Amazon Prime, and it only has a 54% rating on Rotten Tomatoes – solidly mediocre. And yet.

The film does star Sydney Sweeney, however, who also appeared in two massively successful series, Euphoria and White Lotus – both of which earned her Emmy nominations. After photos of Sweeney and Powell together went viral, fans theorised that the co-stars were dating. The actors have maintained that they aren’t together, and Sweeney joked about the rumour in her Saturday Night Live monologue over the weekend. 

Meslow, for one, thinks the idea of the leads also having an offscreen romance likely helped the film, but posits that its popularity has been “largely been resulting from Gen Z moviegoers” – an entire generation whom “Hollywood has by no means significantly courted as a rom-com viewers” earlier than. 

“These Gen-Z moviegoers actually discovered Anybody However You as a word-of-mouth hit, and it is positively price noting that the film’s slow-burn success is due, in no small half, to a viral TikTok development constructed across the Natasha Bedingfield music Unwritten, which options closely within the film’s plot.” The TikTok trend Meslow is referring to has users capturing their vibe after seeing the film. Even Bedingfield herself got in on it, posting her own TikTok mashup.

Anyone But You’s continued success even months after its theatrical debut may signify that audiences – particularly Gen Z – are yearning for a new “golden age” and the next Notting Hill. And Hollywood is paying close attention. 

If you liked this story, sign up for The Essential List newsletter – a handpicked selection of features, videos and can’t-miss news delivered to your inbox every Friday.